I have just completed the setup of KeyMan with ClassicalGreek as described here.
I can now switch back and forth from the Roman alphabet to the Greek alphabet with a simple keyboard shortcut (ctrl+alt+z for me, but you can pick whatever you like!)
The characters are Unicode, of course, so they won’t be visible to users without Unicode support.
I’ve used Keyman for a few years now. Rarely is there a font problem in the ‘normal’ greek unicode range (your test case). But here’s an example from the ‘extended’ greek unicode range - lower case alpha with acute.
ά
It looks to me, at least in ‘Post a reply’ preview, like a ‘box’ glyph. This is standard browser behavior when the character, decimal 8049 in this case, does not map to any glyph in the effective font.
Please note that I run my IE with a unicode font (Arial Unicode MS). I am regularly able to see greek glyphs, both in the normal and extended greek unicode ranges. But here, at least in preview, I do not.
Yeah, Firefox on Win 2K also shows proper glyph. IE6 on Win2K does not. (A strange reversal; usually IE gets the fonts right and Mozilla doesn’t).
But the larger problem is that Textkit-ers have different browsers across different platforms. Not all of us can see Unicode characters glyphs correctly.
However unpleasant SPIONIC looks (and its appearance, too, varies by browser/platform), it remains the more democratic of the several solutions.
Unless I am sorely mistaken - always a possibility - it’s not that simple. The ‘beauty’ of SPIONIC is that it knows how to convert betacode (or nearly betacode) to the appropriate greek glyphs. That is, anyone using an ASCII text editor can create greek glyphs.
There is no such capability in the several Unicode fonts, e.g. Gentium. Gentium can properly show the glyph ‘greek small alpha plus oxia’ in response to the character 8049, but it can’t convert the two ASCII characters a/ to the same glyph.
Try it yourself. Create a syntactically correct HTML file with this SPAN tag in the BODY:
a/
Open it in, say, IE. You should see alpha with an acute accent. Now change the tag to this:
a/
and reload the web page. You should see ‘a/’.
In fine, not only is it a matter of having the right font, but of being able to generate the proper characters. NB: ‘character’ does not mean ‘glyph’; it means the underlying numeric value which is mapped to a glyph by a font.
Yes, exactly. And that’s my point. To effectively use a Unicode font, Textkit-ers would need to be able to enter Unicode data.
I suppose everyone could avail themselves of Keyman or something else like it. But I don’t think everyone will be happy about this. I know there are some Unicode issues in older Windows (98, ME). Also, I don’t know if this approach lends itself to non-Windows platforms.
Personally, I’d be much happier with a Unicode based solution. In fact, when I was new to Textkit I raised this very issue. But now it seems to me that SPIONIC is the simplest, one size fits all solution.
Just wanted to let you know that I see your Greek characters, including Paul’s
lower case alpha with acute. I’m using Netscape on a Mac (currently ver. 10.2.8
Thanks for the link to KeyMan. I’ll try out the program at home with my pc. I don’t think it’ll work for Macs.
Isn’t better to drop all these dasia and oxia etc. and use only one sign for the accent? Than you wouldn’t have any problems with Unicode. I think, the ancient Greeks didn’t use these dasia and oxia nonsense but it is a late invention of the Alexandrian grammarians.
hi thomas, that would be fine for people who use the stress accent to pronounce greek.
the accents represent different pitches though for people who use the pitch accent pronunciation… it wouldn’t make sense to use one symbol for 3 different pitch accents…
It is much more useful to learn vocabulary and grammar, then waisting my time with pitches and how to pronounce them all. I haven’t met anyone who could manage it, e.g. when to use circumflex and how to speak it. It’s a totally waist of time and perhaps also money. That explains why the ancients didn’t bother too much with that and soon dropped them all to one single sign for the stress accent. I myself often do not write even the stress accent.