ἀγών
1) Is the alpha long or short? (I assume short but don't know why.)
2) How do we (ie the community of classicists) know whether it is long or short? Via poetry? Or some rule of which I am unaware?
3) How do I know whether it is long or short, since LSJ don't seem to say? (Maybe answered by 2, maybe not.)
Thanks in advance.
ἀγών
- Scribo
- Global Moderator
- Posts: 917
- Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2008 2:28 pm
- Location: Between Ilias and Odysseia (ok sometimes Athens).
Re: ἀγών
It is indeed short, yes.pster wrote:ἀγών
1) Is the alpha long or short? (I assume short but don't know why.)
Several ways of knowing, of which poetry is just one. First off, comparative data e.g Sanskrit /ajati/ (actually there is a whole boring debate about derivation from PIE * *h₂eǵ) where it is short. More importantly is the fact that despite being an inherited lexeme and existing in Mycenaean too it hasn't gone into any of the sound changes it might have, had it been long.pster wrote:2) How do we (ie the community of classicists) know whether it is long or short? Via poetry? Or some rule of which I am unaware?
In the real meat and bones of the matter, is the fact that it's derived from the verb άγω, so look how that is augmented and reduplicated. Likewise examine how the word acts with prepositions and other derivatives, how it's effected by crasis etc.
So, I think that answers 3 as well. I hope that's not too poorly written.
3) How do I know whether it is long or short, since LSJ don't seem to say? (Maybe answered by 2, maybe not.)
Thanks in advance.[/quote]
(Occasionally) Working on the following tutorials:
(P)Aristotle, Theophrastus and Peripatetic Greek
Intro Greek Poetry
Latin Historical Prose
(P)Aristotle, Theophrastus and Peripatetic Greek
Intro Greek Poetry
Latin Historical Prose
-
- Textkit Zealot
- Posts: 762
- Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2007 3:52 pm
Re: ἀγών
hi, the most concrete way to determine this is to do a search for the word in the iambic sections of aeschylus, sophocles or euripides and see if the syllable sits in (out of the 12 positions) positions 3, 7 or 11 (which only accept light syllables) in which case the vowel is short, or in any of the even positions (2, 4, 6, 8, 10 or 12) which only accept heavy syllables, provided that it's in a single unresolved syllable (i.e. there aren't 2 short syllables in that position) and is in an open syllable (i.e. the syllable isn't made heavy by having a short vowel but closed by consonants), in which case the vowel is long (that's a bit complicated i realise).
so in your case, see aeschylus persians 405: θήκας τε προγόνων: νῦν ὑπὲρ πάντων ἀγών.
ἀ is in position 11, and so it's short.
you can't trust any of the vowels in positions 1, 5 or 9 because these are ancipites which accept light or heavy syllables.
for more background see pgs 3-4 of my article here on writing iambics:
http://www.aoidoi.org/articles/meter/WritingIambics.pdf
and then see how i have determined the vowel length in aeschylus' agamemnon in the red lines on the left on pgs 58 to 69 of this iambic document here:
http://mhninaeide.webs.com/GrkIambicComp-23-Apr-06.pdf
in that doc i followed the procedure i mentioned at the beginning - to determine the vowel length in the ancipites, i found the vowel in another line in a non-anceps position.
cheers, chad
so in your case, see aeschylus persians 405: θήκας τε προγόνων: νῦν ὑπὲρ πάντων ἀγών.
ἀ is in position 11, and so it's short.
you can't trust any of the vowels in positions 1, 5 or 9 because these are ancipites which accept light or heavy syllables.
for more background see pgs 3-4 of my article here on writing iambics:
http://www.aoidoi.org/articles/meter/WritingIambics.pdf
and then see how i have determined the vowel length in aeschylus' agamemnon in the red lines on the left on pgs 58 to 69 of this iambic document here:
http://mhninaeide.webs.com/GrkIambicComp-23-Apr-06.pdf
in that doc i followed the procedure i mentioned at the beginning - to determine the vowel length in the ancipites, i found the vowel in another line in a non-anceps position.
cheers, chad
- pster
- Textkit Zealot
- Posts: 1089
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2009 3:05 am
- Location: Magna Graecia
Re: ἀγών
Thanks to both of you.
But I chose it rather randomly. There are I presume zillions of examples in Greek. And plenty even in Mastronarde. He frequently tells the reader vowel lengths. But I noticed today that many still fall through the cracks. Shouldn't LSJ be telling me?!?! How is the simple student of Greek supposed to read it aloud when these things aren't specified. So many damned do-dads on the letters and still questions remain!
But I chose it rather randomly. There are I presume zillions of examples in Greek. And plenty even in Mastronarde. He frequently tells the reader vowel lengths. But I noticed today that many still fall through the cracks. Shouldn't LSJ be telling me?!?! How is the simple student of Greek supposed to read it aloud when these things aren't specified. So many damned do-dads on the letters and still questions remain!
-
- Textkit Zealot
- Posts: 762
- Joined: Tue Sep 18, 2007 3:52 pm
Re: ἀγών
hi, you often need to look it up in the iambics, scansion of a text can take a bit. with poetry like homer it's easy because you don't need to look it up, with iambics it requires looking up any dubious ancipites, with prose you need to look up a fair bit, less though the more verse comp you do. also i forgot to say that position 12 can't be trusted either, a light or heavy syllable can go there. cheers, chad
-
- Textkit Zealot
- Posts: 2090
- Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 10:15 pm
Re: ἀγών
The on-line edition of LSJ and the Intermediate L&S generally indicate the quantity of alpha, iota and u psilon with the letter in brackets right next to the first entry, followed by either a superscript caret (for a short vowel) or a line (for a long vowel). (In the print edition, the bracketed letter in question is marked with a breve or a macron.)
From the on-line LSJ entry:
From the on-line LSJ entry:
Here's how the on-line LSJ indicates a long u psilon:ἀγών [α^], ῶνος, ὁ,
In the case of a compound or derived word, you may have to look for the base word. And, of course, there may be words for which the quantity of an iota or u psilon can't be determined -- where the letter in question is followed by two vowels and etymology is obscure. Usually long alpha will have changed to eta in Attic.ὕλη [υ_], ἡ,