Textkit Logo

Please, help with Commentariolum petitionis

Here's where you can discuss all things Latin. Use this board to ask questions about grammar, discuss learning strategies, get translation help and more!

Moderator: thesaurus

Please, help with Commentariolum petitionis

Postby Artemidoros » Mon Mar 22, 2004 10:56 am

Hello to all,
I am reading the Commentariolum petitionis, (The Handbook of Elections) a great little work, probably written by Quintus Cicero, Marcus' brother. He describes all the ropes of an electoral campaign in Rome (great read, anyway). There is a phrase which I find rather difficult to translate. Quintus is talking about sodalitates, kind of associations used for electoral purposes. These were on the edge of legality and in fact were made illegal some years later. Well, Quintus tells that he was actually there when his older brother met the leaders of four sodalitates who pledged to help Marcus Cicero in his election. I give you the whole paragraph:

Nam hoc biennio quattuor sodalitates hominum ad ambitionem gratiosissimorum tibi obligasti, C. Fundani, Q. Galli, C. Corneli, C. Orchivi; horum in causis ad te deferendis quid tibi eorum sodales receperint et confirmarint scio, nam interfui; qua re hoc tibi faciendum est, hoc tempore ut ab his quod debent exigas saepe commonendo, rogando, confirmando, curando ut intellegant nullum se umquam aliud tempus habituros referendae gratiae; profecto homines et spe reliquorum tuorum officiorum et[iam] recentibus beneficiis ad studium navandumn excitabuntur


It is just the offer of those four men which I do not understand:
horum in causis ad te deferendis qud tibi eorum sodales receperint et confirmarint scio, nam interfui


Any ideas? (especially "in causis ad te deferendis"). Thanks!
User avatar
Artemidoros
Textkit Neophyte
 
Posts: 21
Joined: Wed Aug 27, 2003 7:56 am
Location: Helvetia

Postby Ulpianus » Tue Mar 23, 2004 12:19 am

I find this very hard. I think I would understand it along these lines, though I feel highly lacking in confidence that I am correct. It's often easier, at least, to work from the errors of others rather than one's own blank slate.

"I know, since I was present, what these men's cronies accepted and guaranteed to you while their [sc., the four named individuals'] cases were being entrusted to you"

i.e., as I take it:

the assumed recipient of the advice either acted as counsel on behalf of the named men or possibly he acted as judge (since causam deferre can mean "bring to court", but we then have to account for "ad te", I do not know whether "causam ad te deferre" can mean "bringing a case to court before you as judge", though the notion that corrupt favouritism shown while on the bench might bring rewards at the next stage of the cursus honorum is not completely foreign, I fear, to Republican Rome, so I guess we must preserve it as a possible meaning, unless context or background eliminates it).

I think we have to take the sodales (not the named individuals) as the subject of reciperint and confirmarint, but in this I seem to differ from your approach. But I am otherwise embarrassed by a surplus of nominatives or accusatives.

I take "in" to mean "while", which is perhaps unusual but not impossible.

I think horum must go with causis though (I suppose) it could just be a very loose genitive of respect, sort of "Concerning whom ... I know ", but that seems intolerably loose.
Ulpianus
Textkit Member
 
Posts: 197
Joined: Fri Jan 23, 2004 3:14 pm
Location: London, UK


Return to Learning Latin

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: bedwere, Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot] and 87 guests